| Earnings Management - Accounting
Red Flags
Page 2 of 6
Richard J. Wayman
Accelerating Revenue
This technique allows companies to record revenue in the current
quarter (accelerating revenue) while delaying recognition of
the related costs (delaying expenses) for several quarters or
years. This can boost revenue for the early quarters, but if
business activity slows (due to a recession), earnings will
drop significantly as revenue growth falls and expenses remain
unchanged.
Global Crossing is currently being criticized for selling long-term
contracts (sometimes called indefeasible rights of use) that
allow other telecommunications companies to use their fiber
routes. Global booked the lump sum payment as revenue in the
quarter it received the cash payment, although the service was,
in fact, supposed to be delivered over a period of several years.
Global also entered into separate contracts with another (or
possibly the same) telecom to buy capacity on their fiber and
recorded these costs as a capital expense that was spread out
over the life of the contract (also several years) and which
resulted in small quarterly expenses. In essence, Global was
accounting for all the revenue from providing a service in a
single quarter, while accounting for the cost of providing that
service over several years. In general, watch out when revenue
and costs for the same product are accounted for over different
timeframes. In Global's case, companies were willing to enter
into these contracts while the economy was booming and the dot-com
bubble was growing. As both collapsed, these companies faced
falling prices, excess capacity and nobody wanted to enter into
any more long-term agreements. As a consequence, Global's and
many other telecoms' revenue growth slammed to a halt and these
companies now face high fixed costs or are forced to write off
these expenses.
|